Political Breakdown
Newsom’s Best and Worst Moments as CA Governor
11/20/2026 | 30m 50sVideo has Closed Captions
A look back at the defining moments of Gavin Newsom’s eight years as California governor.
As Gavin Newsom prepares to leave office, Marisa Lagos, Scott Shafer and Guy Marzorati are joined by Politico’s Jeremy B. White to revisit the defining moments of his governorship. They discuss the COVID-19 pandemic, the French Laundry controversy, his clashes with President Trump, Proposition 50 and the future of California’s high-speed rail project.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Political Breakdown is a local public television program presented by KQED
Political Breakdown
Newsom’s Best and Worst Moments as CA Governor
11/20/2026 | 30m 50sVideo has Closed Captions
As Gavin Newsom prepares to leave office, Marisa Lagos, Scott Shafer and Guy Marzorati are joined by Politico’s Jeremy B. White to revisit the defining moments of his governorship. They discuss the COVID-19 pandemic, the French Laundry controversy, his clashes with President Trump, Proposition 50 and the future of California’s high-speed rail project.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Political Breakdown
Political Breakdown is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship- Should Gavin Newsom run for president, I think his biggest liability could well be the perception of inauthenticity.
- Totally.
- And here's this guy who does what's politically popular.
He's kind of this guy in the suit.
And Governor, if you're watching, I know you don't see yourself this way.
- Hey everyone, from KQED in San Francisco, this is Political Breakdown.
I'm Marisa Lagos here today with KQED Scott Shafer and Guy Marzorati and Politico's Jeremy B. White.
Today on the breakdown, the end of an era in Sacramento.
Governor Gavin Newsom will leave office in January, capping a wild and unpredictable eight years as leader of the nation's largest state.
And as Newsom approaches the end of his tenure and perhaps moves closer to that widely expected run for president, we are dedicating today's show to looking back.
Today is a reflection on the top defining moments of Newsom's governorship with the four of us who have been here since the beginning.
Hey guys.
- Hello.
Hey.
- Well, this is going to be interesting.
Okay, we all spent some time this week making these lists, right?
I want to catch our listeners up.
So we all came up with a secret list of Newsom's top moments.
And before we started the show, we drew names to decide who gets to go first, what the order is.
So the deal is you're going to throw out whatever this moment was and then we'll all talk about it and discuss it.
Jeremy, you get to start us off.
- Perfect.
- Okay.
So rather than opening with the one that I know we're all going to pick, which is that weird thing with the minions at Universal Studios moment.
I'm going to go with one that actually technically happened before he was governor, which is going to tour the damage from the devastating wildfires in paradise.
I had this too.
With President Donald Trump.
And I think that's an important moment in a couple ways.
For one thing, it pre-figured this constant battling with devastating wildfires.
PG&E would go bankrupt soon thereafter, an issue that he ended up trying to deal with again in his waning days and couldn't quite get it done.
And it was also a first taste of this relationship with Donald Trump that in so many ways was going to define Gavin Newsom, sometimes as with Paradise trying to work together, often antagonistic.
But I think in a lot of ways that moment was one that really was kind of a preview of what was coming.
- Yeah.
I will add to that.
I kind of had the entire pre-inaugural era because if you remember the day before the campfire broke out, there was that horrible shooting down in Thousand Oaks at the bar.
- Yes.
- And I was reading back at these clips, like Newsom had a news conference that day that the fire started the day after that shooting.
He had planned to discuss housing and homelessness at a press conference in San Francisco and was going to serve lunch at a, you know, local charity and he had to totally pivot.
And to me, it just speaks to like, you don't get to pick - - Yeah.
Every time we criticize Becerra for not laying out the agenda, I always think of moments like this.
- Yeah.
- As governor, sometimes you don't pick the issues.
- The issues pick you.
Absolutely.
- For - Sure.
The other thing that's interesting, Jeremy, about that moment was just the dynamic between obviously Trump and Newsom, but also Newsom and Jerry Brown, of course.
You know, they have had kind of a, I would say somewhat fraught relationship.
You know Jerry was kind of his uncle in a way when he was growing up.
You, he pointed his dad to the court.
And I think that my impression we spent, Guy and I spent a lot of time with Jerry Brown on that oral history and I kind of got the sense that Jerry didn't hold him in the highest of esteem.
I would, I - - He was a kid to him.
- He was a kid.
- He saw him as a younger, you know, like not as a full adult.
- I, I think he probably now would, would say that he's done a pretty good job as governor, but at that time, not so much.
- And Gavin Newsom now in his sort of contemplative elder statesman role - - His salt and pepper hair.
- Salt and pepper hair.
- Yeah.
- He now talks about his feeling of sort of understanding Jerry Brown more and oh, I'm old news and everybody cares about the next thing.
And he, he's starting to sound a little more like Jerry Brown.
He still doesn't drop a lot of Latin, but nevertheless.
- Yeah, no.
And he also said like the reason he didn't endorse anybody in the governance race is that like Jerry Brown didn't endorse anybody, so I don't have to either.
- Got it.
All right.
Scott, you are up next.
- All right.
This is not a surprise.
This one is his like second month in office.
It's March of 2019 and he declares a moratorium on executions in California.
And to me, this is important because obviously he went on to do other things.
We can talk about the commutations that he did much later just a few weeks ago, but he also dismantled the execution chamber at San Quentin.
It was part of a larger criminal justice effort that he did.
He's closed several prisons.
And it's also, I think, on brand for Newsom because he really swings for the fence.
You know, he goes for those big sort of performative but also substantive things.
He did that with gay marriage when he was mayor.
And so to me, that was like something that kind of rippled throughout the eight years that the emphasis on criminal justice reform.
- Okay.
And something that he obviously has grappled with since, right?
I mean, this is a bookend to his time - - Absolutely.
- In the governor's office making this decision recently on the commutations.
- And I think also a contrast with Jerry Brown.
I mean, Jerry Brown, the first time he was governor was sort of haunted by the death penalty.
We appointed Rose Bird, who later got recalled.
And you know, Jerry Brown could have done what Newsom did.
He, he was certainly at least as also a Jesuit, you know, training.
- Had called his dad as a college student saying, "Don't execute Caryl Chessman."
- Exactly.
- Yeah.
- Yeah.
And he didn't do it, you know?
And so you got to give, again, I think Newsom went beyond what Jerry Brown might have done and you know, I think swang, swung for the fences.
And then we'll find out what the Supreme Court does because they're reviewing about 60% of the cases.
- And there's a lawsuit now challenging and all that.
- Yeah.
So we haven't seen the end of that story.
- So I again would put this in a bigger bucket of like him leading on social issues.
I think you can see that with his broader criminal justice.
Before again, he was elected, he championed Prop 64 to legalize cannabis.
He oversaw the execution of that, creating this new agency that, you know, created regulations.
Obviously there' still a lot of bumps with that, but I do think the fact that the self-professed guy who like never smoked weed being like kind of the champion on these social issues for things like cannabis legalizations, never backing down on Prop 36 when there was all this backlash to criminal justice reforms.
I mean, I feel like that is a hallmark of him as a politician in general, Jeremy.
- I'm going to be maybe a bit of a voice of dissension here on this one because I don't disagree with any of you that this was an important moment for Gavin Newsom.
And I think his, clearly his abhorrence of the, of the death penalty is like a deeply held conviction.
I don't doubt the genuineness.
However, I do also think he is very much a politically calculating figure.
And so did he take a political risk by commuting the death sentences, by declaring a moratorium?
Yes.
He never took the biggest political risk, which would be going to the ballot to voters and seeking a permanent end of the death penalty.
And I think that's in part because he understands it's a politically risky proposition.
You put a lot of collective capital and money on the line.
And so I think in ways this is a kind of illustrative of Gavin Newsom where he'll do a big thing, but he won't necessarily do the hardest version.
- Well, in fact, he issued that moratorium just a couple years after voters approved Prop 66.
Right.
Which remember there were two ballot measures that year to under the death penalty, one to eliminate it altogether, that loss, and then one to expedite executions that won.
And so he kind of flew in the face of voters and, you know, obviously didn't go back to the ballot.
I think things have changed enough that if it were on the ballot again, I think maybe depending on when the timing might pass.
- You could also argue it would've been riskier to go one by one through these cases and to like actually have to dig into the details and commute individual sentences rather than a blanket one, right?
I mean - - Yeah.
- If you think about the TV ads, I mean, you know, there's the old Willie Horton ad in 1988 against Dukakis, but you know, you can certainly envision ads if he's running for president with Richard Allen Davis and Polly Klaas.
So you know, there's definitely some risk.
- The class.
- Your old guy, Richard Allen Davis.
- Oh - Yeah.
- I met him.
I met, I did talk to him in death row or he yelled at me basically.
- Which, which no longer exists.
- Right.
But he does.
- You're up number three pick.
- I am up.
All right.
I'm going to go with the obvious one.
French Laundry.
- Number one on my list.
- But I think it's COVID shutdown.
I'm going to put this in a bigger bucket because looking back through the news of that time, it's hard to remember the order of everything.
That didn't happen until November of 2020 and the world was opening back up.
I mean, what Newsom really fell into was just how angry people were by that point on COVID and on the shutdowns.
So before we talk about French Laundry, I just want to make a point about those early days, which you guys remember.
We were hosting daily news conferences.
I was literally in my garage surrounded by camping gear with two toddlers upstairs running around.
And I think at the beginning of COVID, obviously hindsight's twenty twenty.
We can all say now that the school shutdowns were too long, that we could have done better and been more nimble.
But I do think in the dearth of leadership from President Trump at the time and the federal government, Newsom really did step into a vacuum there.
And I would say he did rise to the occasion.
And a lot of the kind of looking back, him securing masks and equipment for nurses and doctors, thinking about the rollout of the vaccine that went pretty well here in California, it is wild that one meal at French Laundry derailed all of it.
- French Laundry is the defining moment of his governorship.
You ask someone on the street, you ask your uncle next week at Thanksgiving, they're going to say French Laundry.
It not only ruined his pandemic glow up, it sparked the recall campaign and it launched him into this really campaign that I would argue probably never finished.
I mean, he ran that recall in a real partisan punch first manner and almost never stopped.
- This is my question.
Yes, it took away that sheen, but did it actually help him longer term?
- Is there a long term?
Possibly.
I mean, it confirmed every worst caricature of him.
The fact that he, and just for folks who did not, I mean, he had a dinner at a restaurant, a very fancy restaurant - - With 12 people.
- In the Napa Valley with 11 of his closest friends bringing together multiple households at a time where his administration was telling people, "Please do not gather three or more households."
Shout out to Alexei Koseff at the San Francisco Chronicle who broke that story.
- Here's a question though.
Let's suppose they had had dinner at, I don't know, Zuni in San Francisco.
Would it have been different?
Was it something about French Laundry, the $12,000 wine bill?
- It was the perfect storm and they were in this private room and then first they lied about it and said they were outside.
Well, it turned out there was doors that they had closed because they were being so loud.
It was with his friend Jason Kinney, who's like a wealthy lobbyist consultant type.
- Well, if you compare also like Gretchen Whitmer, the governor of Michigan, I think got caught in a similar thing, but she was caught eating in a bar, which is so on brand for her with her leather jacket.
And people kind of made fun of it because - - Dude, Mayor London Breed went to Tony, Tony, Tony.
That didn't have the same.
- Pelosi went to.
- She got her hair done.
- So obviously French Laundry is on my list.
I agree with you, Marisa.
I actually had the COVID shutdown as a separate item, but it's all part of the same thing.
And I think another reason that French Laundry and all that followed was such a defining moment is larger than Gavin Newsom, which is don't forget, not long after French Laundry, which then spurred the Newsom recall, we had the school board recalls.
We had the Chesa Boudin recall.
Now we've just seen London Breed, the mayor of San Francisco defeated.
Karen Bass, the mayor of Los Angeles defeated.
And so I think the backlash to it really encapsulated not just this COVID era frustration, but this larger public ferment and this annoyance with incumbents.
And it feels like every campaign cycle is about throw out the incumbents.
- May 2020, Newsom's approval was at 70%.
We are all banging pots and pans out the window for doctors or whatever.
That was over by November.
It was people were upset.
It was, we're now in a second year where my kids can't do in-person schooling.
So the mood at all changed and - - Well, forget everything opened up and then shut back down again.
But I would also argue the tail is longer.
I mean, both, I think this setup, some other things we'll probably talk about, which is his resistance kind of leadership role.
But also, I would argue this helped pave the way for Trump to come back in 24.
Absolutely.
Because even though Trump was in office when this all happened, Biden really got saddled the same way Newsom did with the kind of COVID story of overreach of... And all the backlash around MAHA and the vaccines.
- Then he had COVID for that disastrous debate as well.
I would say just in Newsom's defense, if you look at Andrew Cuomo, who's governor of New York, he was on a roll with his daily briefings.
And then he found out that they were shaving the numbers down on nursing home deaths.
So I think at least in that regard, I mean, Newsom did use COVID - - Our death rate was way lower than other comparable states.
I mean, what he did worked from a health perspective.
- Yeah.
And he tried to take advantage of it in the sense of creating more homeless units and was a project room key and all that.
- But I mean, let's be real.
French Laundry.
- French Laundry.
- Unforgettable.
- And do we feel bad for Thomas Keller and French Laundry at all?
- No, we went a year later and there were people waiting outside because they'd heard about it through Newsom.
It was like the "Harry Met Sally."
I'll want to order what he had.
- We also saw people having their picture taken, which we did too.
- All right, let's move.
It's a nice turn.
- Number four pick, the National Guard goes to Los Angeles.
Yes.
- Yes.
- June 2025, Trump sends in the National Guard.
This was, Newsom responds in a primetime address.
He goes to court against the Trump administration, ultimately wins.
A judge says these National Guard troops cannot be deployed for local law enforcement.
To me, Newsom spent a couple years, 2023, 2024, kind of grasping for a national platform in ways that didn't totally feel relevant.
It was the DeSantis debate, traveling to China, traveling to Israel.
And you saw as a result, his poll numbers go down because I think a lot of Californians felt, "What does this have to do with being governor?"
The National Guard response was beyond relevant.
It was vital.
This was something happening on California streets.
And I think there you also saw the end of that little detante Newsom had with the right.
It was, "I got to work with the president if I have to.
I'll have Charlie Kirk on my show.
I'll have Steve Bannon on my show."
That's not Gavin Newsom.
Gavin Newsom is when they go low, I grab my limbo stick.
He's a pretty me down there now.
He's one of the all-time culture warriors of the 21st century.
And this put him back on that kind of political war footing that he's never kind of pumped the brakes from.
- And I have to wonder if he didn't peak too soon in that regard with the selling the knee pads and all that stuff later on.
But there's no question that's where his national profile went up with that taking on Trump.
- And I was just going to echo what you said, Guy, which is that coming into 2025, there was a lot of talk of sort of conciliation, finding places we can work together.
And if you talk to people in Newsom World, that moment when Donald Trump deployed the National Guard after according to the governor's account, not giving him a heads-up, irrevocably permanently destroyed that relationship.
And in Newsom's eyes, there was some ability to work together.
And that was the moment in which it was like, "That's over.
We're done.
It's now maximum partisan combat all the time."
And it has been ever since.
- Well, it's so interesting because that year and the fires, which is where Trump had come out in January after the horrific fires and was there with Newsom on the ground was really, I think, set the stage for a lot of things in LA that have ended with Karen Bass losing her mayorship, right?
So in some ways that and the National Guard were so disruptive on the ground in LA.
I think they had very different local implications.
But for Newsom, yeah, it gave something for people to rally around.
And it led to this social media sort of posturing that ultimately led into Prop 50, which we might talk about separately.
But I think those are all connected too.
I was in Thailand for the month of July and I had just checked out of the news.
The only thing breaking through on my Instagram feed, which is otherwise like puppies and food, was people sort of retweeting the Newsom kind of aggression at Trump where he was parroting the president's own style.
So yeah, I just think that's a moment where he really found his footing in a way, and it was what the base wanted.
And he has not kind of changed from that, I would say, ever since.
- And the larger conflict, I think also, California's been fighting with Donald Trump for years across multiple administrations in the courts, passing policies to counter Donald Trump, making side deals with automakers, but the symbolism of a proudly diverse immigrant-heavy state and federal enforcement coming in and that moment when Senator Alex Padilla is thrown to the ground by federal agents, there were just all these moments culminating in National Guard.
- I know that was like that week.
- And it just so potently symbolized what was at stake and why California was not going to stand for it that I think, you know, he, with merit, seized on that moment to make a stand and gave that speech saying, "This is the moment we've all feared."
And - That was a moment.
That - - Was like a national address.
- Yes.
- It was like almost from like from the Oval Office.
- Yeah.
- Yeah.
- Jeremy, you are back up.
- I really wanted to do a policy one and this kind of is, but after that last conversation, it has to be Proposition 50, right?
I think we have to do that.
So look, before Donald Trump went to Texas and said, "Make me some new seats," I think Gavin Newsom was a little bit kind of in his lame duck mode.
He had tried to get some stuff done in the legislature that hadn't worked out.
There was a feeling in Sacramento of like, okay, we can see the end.
Democrats are feeling very demoralized after 2024.
And then Donald Trump set off this chain of events that in ways was kind of the perfect political opportunity for Gavin Newsom, working with and at the urging of national Democrats to do something real and concrete and give Democrats who were so dispirited and feeling impotent something to rally behind with Proposition 50.
- Yeah, he had that press conference, I think it was some of the Texas lawmakers who were urging him to counter what Greg Abbott was doing.
And of course it passed overwhelmingly.
I know Guy, you've made the point recently that, well, maybe they didn't really even need to do that because the win a couple weeks ago was so big.
But to your point, Jeremy, it really was what Democrats were needing so badly that boost to somebody, they wanted a fighter.
- Yes.
- And they felt the Democrats were not really taking it to the Republicans.
And he did that.
Now, whether or not, again, I think he may be kind of that brand, it may have peaked a little too soon.
Whether he can ride that into 2028 is another question.
- Yeah, this was next on my list.
It was spot on.
I think this is one of those moments where you see Newsom's political eye, gay marriage, marijuana legalization, redistricting.
Wait a second.
Californians like independent redistricting.
We support our commission.
No, what I'm seeing is this is exactly what voters are going to want in this moment.
Yes.
- And ironically, not unlike several other things on here, a gift from President Trump to Governor Gavin Newsom, right?
To your point, this would not have been possible if Trump hadn't sort of sparked the whole thing.
Newsom certainly wouldn't have taken it on and you wouldn't have had this anger among the base.
And I think that this was the real world policy sort of implementation of that social media strategy that came out in the summer of '25, which was just in real time, how do we take this anger at Washington and put it into something that actually makes sense on the ground?
- Well, and unlike these other states like Florida and Texas, the redistricting here actually worked.
I mean, they did pick up five seats and Calvert and Young Kim went at it against each other.
One of them lost.
So yeah, I think it really worked out.
- You're up number six.
- Just one more quote on this.
I would also just note with Proposition 50, I think a lot of the sort of leaning into the national fight stuff that Gavin Newsom had done up to this point, some folks though it was kind of gimmicky.
You remember how we were going to pass a national gun control amendment, campaign for democracy going into red states, stuff like that, which however much there was merit to it, people were like, "This guy's just trying to build up for presidential one."
This is one that really gave voters something very concrete politically to get behind.
- Yeah, and people got behind it.
All right, mine, there's a bit of a run up to this.
So there's a big bucket of appointments that he's made as governor.
At one point he had both senators where he had appointed Attorney General Rob Banta.
But in 2020, after Kamala Harris becomes vice president, he names Alex Padilla, his friend, the Secretary of State, to be the Senator.
And there was a lot of pushback about that from the Black community, especially because Kamala had been the only Black Senator, Black woman Senator.
And so he goes on The View and he promises that he will, if Feinstein were to step down for some reason, he promised to appoint a Black woman to replace her.
So Feinstein dies.
And so now he's stuck and there's already a race underway to replace her because she wasn't going to run for reelection, but she dies.
And so there was a lot of pressure on him to appoint Barbara Lee, Black woman, to that job.
And obviously Nancy Pelosi would not want that because she wanted Adam Schiff who ultimately won.
So he appoints Laphonza Butler, who is a political operative with deep roots in labor.
I just think that was a brilliant move because he made it sound like, well, she can run if she wants to, because initially he said he wanted an interim, like a caretaker, but he left it up to her to run.
There is no way she was ever going to run, I don't think.
But she got him off the hook in a way that kind of shows the way his mind thinks politically and strategically.
And she's also the first Black lesbian to be a senator.
- I'll just say Scott's larger point about the extent to which Gavin Newsom has reshaped California government with some of these appointments is an important one, whether by endorsing allies or by appointing people.
- Yeah.
And judges, I mean, we could go down the road.
All right.
Well, I would do another sort of bucket here, which is like his anti-tax sort of pro-business framing, which he's managed to kind of hold onto even as he's like a darling of labor.
I think Prop 40 this year is the most recent example of that.
I think the way he's sort of now trying to own AI, even though he vetoed the strongest AI bills a couple years ago.
And then it's just like his personal relationship.
Let's not forget, back in the day he was at Sean Parker's wedding when they ruined that Redwood grove.
There was that story about Sergey Brin at Chris Larson's tree house party sort of confronting him about Prop 40.
I think that his relationship with Silicon Valley has been a sort of under the radar thing that has informed a lot of the way he's governed and it's going to be incredibly important as he looks at a presidential run.
And I think that when you see that, you see it in what we're seeing right now with the budget where he's trying to claim he's left the state with this great budget, but he really hasn't, right?
Because we have such a volatile system.
He's never been willing to take on a reform of the tax system.
And I just think his sort of personal and professional relationships with Silicon Valley have really underlied a lot of how he's governed.
- Well, and it's interesting too, because I don't think that's his image nationally.
He's always been a little moremoderate when he was mayor of San Francisco, when he was governor.
- He's a business guy.
Yeah.
- He's a business guy.
And it's interesting because I think his reputation nationally is like some crazy California liberal, and that's not really who he's been.
- Yeah.
All right, Guy.
- Number eight, high speed rail.
February 2019, say to the state, to quote, "Let's be real.
The project as currently planned would cost too much and take too long.
There's been too little oversight and not enough transparency."
If he had just stopped the quote there, sliding doors moment.
Instead he said, "We do have enough to complete the Merced to Bakersfield link."
That I think could be a regret for Newsom where seven years later, six years later, that project was the poster child for the abundance movement as reclined Derek Thompson.
The idea that Democrats cannot get things built, this is it.
High speed rail.
This didn't have to become his project, but he made it that.
And the fact that he became the most vocal champion for it year after year in the state budget, $15 billion the state has spent.
We still don't have a train.
There's not probably enough money right now to even do the Merced to Bakersfield, let alone the $126 billion San Francisco to LA, which I'm not sure we'll ever see.
There was recently another shakeup at the High Speed Rail Authority.
I think this is one of those moments that could stick with Newsom going forward.
And so that's why it's on my list.
- Anyone want to jump in on that one?
- I mean, who wants to be the governor that pulls the plug on that thing?
- Ask him now.
I don't know.
- Yeah.
I mean, but Sarah also, same thing.
- Especially after this disastrous chair appointment that the guy who just stepped down.
- Yeah, yeah, yeah.
No.
It's just incredibly troubled project, but it's creating jobs and they are laying track, but it's the track to nowhere.
- All right.
Izzy says, "Forget the clock.
We're just going to keep going until we hit 10."
So Jeremy, you're back up.
Incredible.
- Okay.
I'm so excited because I finally get to do a policy.
I know I have these one here too.
A few on my list.
I'm going to go with one that I think most embodies his approach to working with the legislature.
Governor, after catching some flack from environmentalists for not doing enough, summer of 2022, he comes in late and he says, "I want to do a big environmental package."
He pushes it through.
He goes to New York and he says, "I had to jam my own legislature."
And something about how some of them were controlled by the oil industry.
I can promise you nobody in Sacramento has forgotten that.
In fact, a lawmaker gifted Gavin Newsom a jar of jam earlier this summer as a little token of that.
And I think this is one that really illustrated Gavin Newsom's strategy in dealing with the legislature, which is often a source of frustration, which is that he would sort of strategically come in when he and his team felt it was most opportune and say, "We're getting this done."
Understanding the leverage that the governor had.
And in almost every instance, it worked.
He did the same thing with a big infrastructure push.
He did the same thing to do something that had eluded governors for decades and overhaul the California Environmental Quality Act.
And so I've heard plenty of complaints from legislators over the years about sort of being dictated to by this governor who didn't care about them.
- Well, then he flip-flopped on it, right?
He was all about cracking down on the oil industry.
He was investigating them.
And then oil prices started rising.
- I kept this off my list because of that.
I felt like the last two years, the pivot on the refineries, the fears that this would drive up gas prices, the change, even just the last year, the way Cap and Invest rolled out, it looks a lot different than it would've looked a couple years ago when it did seem like he oiled the oil industry was enemy number one for him.
- Yes.
And - Go - Ahead.
- I was just going to agree with that Guy that at the time, remember the oil industry had gone and taken out some ads in Florida criticizing him that really pissed off Gavin Newsom.
And so it was a political decision that these guys are a good foe for me.
Now you see the governor talking about, oh good, we have a pipeline bringing oil in to compensate those refineries going offline.
Well, California's policies are a big reason those refineries.
- Well, in that bucket, I would add Diablo Canyon.
- Yes.
- He ran saying he was going to decommission it early, but definitely not extend its life.
And then he flip-flopped and now it's going to be alive at least through 2035, I think, because he realized nobody wants black energy blackouts.
And it's also, it does help you meet your carbon reduction goals.
But again, it's kind of a flip-flop.
- Yeah.
All right.
- Bring us home, Scott.
- Number 10, you're it.
- Oh, man.
All right.
I'm going to go with March 6th, 2025.
Democrats have been drubbed in the election.
There's all this talk about all the emphasis on transgender stuff and how it killed Kamala Harris.
He starts a new podcast.
This is Gavin Newsom.
First guest, Charlie Kirk.
- That you kind of sounded like him when you said that.
- Charlie Kirk.
- This is Gavin Newsom.
- Gavin Newsom.
And so Charlie Kirk raises the transgender athletes thing, and Newsom agrees with them.
He says, "It's an issue of fairness.
It's deeply unfair."
And then he prays Donald Trump's us versus them ad that really was very effective against Kamala Harris.
And I just think it showed... And he also later, he said that Democrats - Finger in the wind.
Democrats need to be more normal, culturally normal.
And I think it pissed off a lot of people.
- Oh yes.
- And it kind of did show him as an opportunist who was, yeah, okay, the winds are shifting and I got to shift with it.
But now they've kind of shifted back in a way.
So I don't know where he ends up with all that.
- I mean, we pushed him on this a year ago when he was in here and he still sort of hasn't, I think, come up with a good response on it.
His response is like, "Well, I've been a friend of the LGBTQ community."
And you're like, "Okay, but then what does that look like?
What should the conversation be?"
Yeah, I think that, I mean, it wasn't just Charlie Kirk.
I was looking back, that's still the most viewed podcast that he's put out.
It has over one and a half million views.
His podcast does very well.
I mean, I think in general, the fact that we have a governor of a state of 40 million doing a podcast raises questions.
- He was doing two for a while.
What was doing the one with Marshawn Lynch?
- But yeah, I think that that was really him trying to prove he was a different kind of Democrat.
I don't know that it worked, but it is an insurance policy if he loses in 2028.
I mean, he's got that YouTube feed.
- Yeah.
Bring on the competition.
- And I would just echo both Marisa and Scott here, which is that, and I would connect this back to French Laundry too, where should Gavin Newsom run for president, I think his biggest liability could well be the perception of inauthenticity.
- Totally.
- And here's this guy who does what's politically popular.
He's kind of this guy in the suit.
And Governor, if you're watching, I know you don't see yourself this way, and I think that perception is going to continue to dog him.
And to the extent that this was seen as like, oh, he saw where the winds were blowing, so he shifted.
I think that's going to be a hard perception for him to shake.
And this was a moment that, to your point, Scott, I remember talking to a lot of lawmakers, particularly members of the LGBTQ caucus who felt betrayed.
- Yeah, - Absolutely.
Yeah.
- And interesting because in some other issues we've discussed today, he has seen around the corner in ways, right?
And he's taken risks.
And I think that that's - The death penalty.
- Yeah.
I would say - - Gay marriage.
- Yeah.
I had the support opposing Prop 36 moment on my list just because climate change, you can make the argument on healthcare, even LGBTQ issues like he's seen where things are going.
Criminal justice is not that for him.
That's always been one where as Kendrick Perkins would say, stand on business.
- Okay.
Well, and we're going to leave it here.
I will say just in case anybody still listening is mad at us for not getting deep into policy, we will be having those discussions in the coming weeks.
This was a little bit more fun though.
Thanks guys.
What a great discussion.
- This great.
That fun.
- That's going to be a wrap for Political Breakdown.
We're a production of KQED.
Our engineer today is Christopher Beale.
Our producer is Izzy Bloom.
Our video team includes Derek Lartaud, Rick Santangelo, Kate Lowpensky, and Vivian Morales.
I'm Marisa Lagos here with Scott Shafer, Guy Marzorati, and Jeremy B. White.
We'll see you next time.
New Episode- News and Public Affairs

Top journalists deliver compelling original analysis of the hour's headlines.
New Episode- Drama

Benjamin Wainwright stars as Maigret in the contemporary adaptation of Georges Simenon's novels.
New Episode
Recently Added
New Episode
New Season





Support for PBS provided by:
Political Breakdown is a local public television program presented by KQED
