
April 14, 2025 - PBS News Hour full episode
4/14/2025 | 57m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
April 14, 2025 - PBS News Hour full episode
Monday on the News Hour, both President Trump and El Salvador's president indicate they have no intention of returning a man mistakenly deported. On-again, off-again tariffs on electronics imported to the U.S. from China add to the confusion for companies around the world. Plus, the scientific efforts to reduce methane emissions on cattle farms by changing the animals' diet.
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
Major corporate funding for the PBS News Hour is provided by BDO, BNSF, Consumer Cellular, American Cruise Lines, and Raymond James. Funding for the PBS NewsHour Weekend is provided by...

April 14, 2025 - PBS News Hour full episode
4/14/2025 | 57m 46sVideo has Closed Captions
Monday on the News Hour, both President Trump and El Salvador's president indicate they have no intention of returning a man mistakenly deported. On-again, off-again tariffs on electronics imported to the U.S. from China add to the confusion for companies around the world. Plus, the scientific efforts to reduce methane emissions on cattle farms by changing the animals' diet.
Problems with Closed Captions? Closed Captioning Feedback
How to Watch PBS News Hour
PBS News Hour is available to stream on pbs.org and the free PBS App, available on iPhone, Apple TV, Android TV, Android smartphones, Amazon Fire TV, Amazon Fire Tablet, Roku, Samsung Smart TV, and Vizio.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipWILLIAM BRANGHAM: Good evening.
I'm William# Brangham.
Amna Nawaz and Geoff Bennett are away.
On the "News Hour" tonight:# During a White House visit,## both President Trump and El Salvador's# president indicate they have no intention## of returning a man mistakenly# deported, despite a court order.
On-again/off-again tariffs on# electronics imported to the U.S.## from China add to the confusion# for companies around the world.
And the scientific efforts to reduce methane## emissions on cattle farms by# changing the animals' diet.
ERMIAS KEBREAB, University of California, Davis:# I think we can produce high-quality protein,## high-quality milk, at the# same time help the planet.
(BREAK) WILLIAM BRANGHAM:##Welcome to the "News Hour."
A remarkable scene inside the Oval Office# today, President Trump.. his administration meeting with# the president of El Salvador,## both governments rejecting the president's# request for responsibility for the fate of## a Maryland man the administration# admits was wrongly deported.
The Supreme Court decided last week the U.S.# government must facilitate the return of Kilmar## Abrego Garcia.
Attorney General Pam Bondi said# Garcia's return is at El Salvador's discretion.
PAM BONDI, U.S. Attorney General: He was# illegally in our country.
He had been## illegally in our country.
Right now, it was a# paperwork -- it was additional paperwork that## needed to be done.
That's up to El Salvador if# they want to return him.
That's not up to us.
The Supreme Court rule, President, that# if El Salvador wants to return him,## this is international matters, foreign# affairs.
If they wanted to return him,## we would facilitate it, meaning provide a plane.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: But President Bukele# also claimed his hands were tied.
NAYIB BUKELE, President of El Salvador:# How can I return him to the United States?## It's like I smuggle him into the United# States, or whatever it is?
Of course,## I'm not going to do it.
It's like, I mean, the# question is preposterous.
How can I smuggle a## terrorist into the United States?
I don't have# the power to return him to the United States.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: For more, I am joined# by our White House correspondent,## Laura Barron-Lopez, who has# been covering the latest.
Hi.
LAURA BARRON-LOPEZ: Hi.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Help us understand# th.. between these two presidents we saw# sitting next to each other today.
LAURA BARRON-LOPEZ: So, first, some# background on President Bukele.
He## has described himself as -- quote# -- "the world's coolest dictator."
And President Bukele essentially believes that# when someone is president, they become the law.## He's not known in his country for respecting# the rights of people inside the criminal justice## system.
And he has been politically rewarded back# home for creating these mega-prisons that now the## United States is sending migrants to, because# his voters believe that they have reduced crime.
And so it is believed that President Bukele,# unlike other Latin American presidents,## has demonstrated essentially that he's# willing to imprison a number of people## that President Trump sends to him,# including potentially U.S. citizens,## which President Trump was asked# about the possibility of today.
DONALD TRUMP, President of the United# States: If they're criminals and if## they hit people with baseball bats over# their head that happen to be 9.. and if they rape 87-year-old women# in Coney Island, Brooklyn, yes, yes,## that includes them.
What, do you think# there's special category of person?
They're as bad as anybody that comes in.# We have bad ones too.
And I'm all for it.# LAURA BARRON-LOPEZ: President Trump,## as they were entering the Oval Office,# had said to El Salvadoran.. Bukele that -- quote -- "homegrowns are# next," referring to American citizens.
And he was asking Bukele to build# five more mega-prisons.
Also,## just yesterday, we should note that 10# more migrants who the administration## alleges are members of MS-13 and Tren# de Aragua were deported to El Salvador.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: This comes also# as we saw another late-night filing## from the Trump administration arguing# that they have no responsibility to## bring Kilmar Abrego Garcia back# from that El Salvador prison.
LAURA BARRON-LOPEZ: That's right.
Yesterday, the a.. secure" in the CECOT mega-prison.# But the federal judge, Paula Xinis,## had ordered daily updates about what they# were doing to bring back Abrego Garcia.
And the administration said in that filing# -- quote -- "The federal courts have no## authority to direct the executive# branch to conduct foreign relations## in a particular way or engage with a# foreign sovereign in a given manner."
Now, also today, Stephen Miller, a top adviser# to President Trump, falsely claimed that the## Supreme Court said that the lower district's# ruling was unlawful.
Also, he claimed that## the Supreme Court unanimously sided with the# White House in this issue.
And that's not true.
The Supreme Court specifically said# that the administration must facilitate## Garcia's -- quote -- "release from custody" in El# Salvador and that the Trump administration needed## to be prepared to share details about what# they were doing to facilitate that release.
Now, SCOTUS has also ruled that due process is# necessary for anyone that the administration is## deporting in the manner that they had deported# Abrego Garcia.
And Trump officials repeatedly## claimed today that Garcia himself is a# member of MS-13, but the appeals court## has said that the administration has provided no# evidence that he is a member of the MS-13 gang.
So, when you break it down, William, a number of# things that were said today by Trump officials,## including A.G. Pam Bondi, including# Secretary of State Marco Rubio,## is the opposite of what the administration# is saying in court.
They have repeatedly## admitted in court that they# made an administrative error.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: So where does# it leave it with the judge who## said to the administration, you# have got to make this happen?
LAURA BARRON-LOPEZ: I spoke to Ira# Kurzban.
He's a longtime immigration## lawyer.
And he said that ultimately the# federal judge could ask to see that $6## million contract to figure out if the# administration is not telling the truth.
And he also said, though, that the continued# defiance of the court's orders in the Abrego## Garcia case, as well as efforts# to target other legal immigrants,## ultimately is all about self-deportation.
IRA KURZBAN, Immigration Attorney: This is# just all a political construct by Trump to## scare the American people.
And this is all in# many respects theater.
It's all designed -- and## even his statement, I'm going to take Americans# and send them there, it's all designed to get## people so afraid that they leave the United# States.
That's what this is really all about.
LAURA BARRON-LOPEZ: Ultimately,# Abrego Garcia case could have big## implications for the other Venezuelans and# migrants that were deported to El Salvador.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: In another front on# the Trump anti-immigration campaign,## there was this hearing about the Tufts# University student Rumeysa Ozturk## who was detained for her alleged support# of Hamas.
What is the latest on that?
LAURA BARRON-LOPEZ: So what we found out was# that The Washington Post exclusively reported## that the State Department has no evidence that# the Tufts University student Ozturk engaged in## antisemitic activities, nor did she make public# statements supporting terrorist organizations.
And in a hearing today, a federal judge said that## he may ultimately rule that she needs# to be released from Louisiana detention## and he raised the possibility that this# could lead to a constitutional crisis.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Laura Barron-Lopez,# as always, thank you so much.
LAURA BARRON-LOPEZ: Thank you.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: The escalating# trade war between the U.S. and## China is continuing to inject uncertainty# into the world's two largest economies.
Over the weekend, President Donald Trump# and his top trade officials added to the## confusion by carving out new exemptions# for tariffs on electronic products.
In the Oval Office today, reporters pressed## President Trump on where this# tumultuous trade war is heading.
DONALD TRUMP, President of# the United States: Look, I'm## a very flexible pe.. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: The president declined## to specify what products might# be exempt from f.. DONALD TRUMP: I don't want to hurt# anybody, but the end result is,## we're going to get to the position# of greatness for our country.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: This morning,# Wall Street opened on a high note,## markets reacting positively to the weekend# announcement of exemptions for smartphones,## computers and other tech carved out of the# Trump administration's sweeping global tariffs.
But those celebrations may be brief, as U.S.# trade policy continues to swing back and forth.
On## Sunday, the president told reporters on Air Force# One that there could be tariffs coming on iPhones.
DONALD TRUMP: Well, that's# going to be announced very soon,## and we will be discussing it, but# we will also talk to companies.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: But, yesterday,# Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick## was definitive that new tariffs are coming for# tech products made with semiconductor chips.
HOWARD LUTNICK, U.S. Commerce Secretary: These# are included in the semiconductor tariffs that## are coming and the pharmaceuticals are# coming.
Those two areas are coming in## the next month or two.
So this is not# like a permanent sort of exemption.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: All of this after a# dramatic week for Wall Street.
On April 2,## President Trump announced massive# tariffs on most of the world.
DONALD TRUMP: My fellow# Americans, this is liberation day.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: A week later,# he walked back most of them,## saying he'd begin a 90-day negotiation period.
But tariffs on Chinese-made# goods were not paused.
Instead,## they were increased to 145 percent.
That left# some tech companies like Apple in the lurch.
LIN JIAN, Chinese Foreign Ministry Spokesperson# (through translator): The U.S. uses tariffs as## a weapon for extreme pressure and self-interest,## placing its own interests above# those of the international community.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: China has remained firm# against what it calls bullying from America,## adding their own 125 percent# tariffs on U.S. goods.
Today, Beijing also escalated by halting exports# of certain rare earth minerals and magnets,## critical components for computer chips, cars# and many kinds of electric motors and other## technologies.
Chinese President Xi Jinping has# been reaching out to other countries.
Today,## he kicked off a tour of Southeast Asia in# Vietnam, signing a series of agreements.
In Washington, President Trump said he likes# President Xi, but not his meeting with Vietnam.
DONALD TRUMP: I don't blame China.# I don't blame Vietnam.
I see they're## meeting today.
Isn't that wonderful?
And# it's a lovely meeting.
They're meeting## like trying to figure out, how do we# screw the United States of America?
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: For now, markets appear to# be optimistic, as tech companies help to lift## Wall Street today.
The Dow Jones industrial# average finished up by more than 300 points.## The Nasdaq notched its own 100-point# gain, and the S&P climbed by 0.8 percent.
So, for more on how this trade war is playing out,# we turn again, as we often do, to David Wessel.## He's the director of the Hutchins Center on Fiscal# and Monetary Policy at the Brookings Institution.
David, always great to have# you back on the program.
Help us understand something.
When you look# back at the last few weeks of this trade war,## imbroglio, however you want to describe it,## can you discern a strategy# from the administration here?
DAVID WESSEL, Brookings Institution: In# short, no.
It seems to be incoherent.## Different voices in the administration# say different goals for the tariffs.
Are## they to raise money to cover the cost of# tax cuts?
Are they a negotiating tool for## the president to get more access to foreign# markets for us?
Are they national security?
So I think we do know that# the president likes tariffs,## and his staff is determined to find# ways to justify them.
And, secondly,## there is a clear attempt to get more manufacturing# to return from the U.S., particularly in goods## like pharmaceuticals and semiconductors# that he considers national security.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: I mean, the supporters of# the president argue that this may be messy,## but that the pain is going to be worth the gain,## that this is -- as some have put it, that# this is watching art of the deal unfold.
Do you see anything that is unfolding here that# could be strengthening America's negotiating hand?
DAVID WESSEL: I don't, William.
I'm afraid that the president has weakened# our standing in the world economy.## If the goal was to put pressure on China, then# the one would think the goal would have -- the## tactic would have been to get allies like# Canada, Mexico and Europe on our side.
So I think it's very hard.
The -- Chris# Waller, who's the chair of a -- member## of the Federal Reserve board, said today# that it's the biggest shock that the world## economy has seen in a long time, and that one# problem is both the policy and the effects are## uncertain.
And that doesn't seem a great# recipe for building a strong economy here.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: On that shock to the U.S.# economy, where is that most being felt right now?
DAVID WESSEL: Well, in our# country, it's being felt,## I think, by businesses and maybe some# consumers just pulling back.
If you're## not sure what the policy of the government# is going to be on the goods that you import,## or the parts you need to make your product,# you're going to be less willing to expand.
So there's a lot of talk about uncertainty.# And I think what that means is, if you're## not -- if it's not clear what's going to# happen, you pull back.
If everybody delays,## that's how we get a recession.
And a lot of# forecasters are anticipating a recession.
One really worrisome sign here is not the# stock market, but what's happened to the## bond market and the value of the dollar.
And,# basically, yields on treasury bonds have gone up,## the value of the dollar has gone down.
And# some people are interpreting that as an## indication that the world is less confident# about the safety of investing in the U.S. And that would be a long -- if# that's true, if that persists,## that will have long-lasting# effects, and they're not good ones.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: You mentioned the concern# over a possible recession.
Polls certainly## show that consumers are concerned about that.# Some major Wall Street firms are the same.
Do you feel that's a legitimate# concern?
Are we really at risk of that?
DAVID WESSEL: Well, at risk, sure.# But is it likely?
I don't know.
It## depends.
It depends how quickly the# president gets his act together.
And if this is a negotiating tool and we# have some deals, maybe they're cosmetic,## but allows him to back off, we have# a 10 percent across-the-board tariff,## but that's all it is, and some strategic# tariffs, if things calm down, if it looks## like adults are in charge in Washington,# that would reduce the risk of recession.
And some depends on what the Federal Reserve# does here.
The Federal Reserve is an awkward## position.
On one hand, tariffs will make prices# go up.
On the other hand, they could make the## economy grow more slowly.
And so they have to# decide, at what point do they act?
So far, it## looks like they're sitting on their hands.
That's# not going to be helpful to avoid a recession.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: All right, David# Wessel of the Brookings Institution,## always so good to hear your# counsel.
Thank you very much.
DAVID WESSEL: You're welcome.
I'm# sorry I couldn't be more upbeat.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM:## We begin the day's other headlines with new# details about the man accused of setting fire## to the Pennsylvania governor's mansion Sunday;## 38-year-old Cody Balmer has been charged with# arson, attempted homicide, and terrorism.
Court documents say he jumped over a fence to# gain entry, used handmade Molotov cocktails## to set the mansion fire, and planned to beat# Governor Josh Shapiro with a hammer if he ever## found him.
Shapiro and his family were safely# evacuated.
No one was injured.
Authorities have## not stated a motive for the attack.
Shapiro# said he and his family celebrated the Jewish## holiday of Passover just hours before# in the same room that was set ablaze.
Unsealed federal court documents reveal that# a Wisconsin teenager arrested last month for## killing his parents did so to take their money# and carry out a plot to assassinate President## Trump.
The documents further said the suspect# identified with a satanic neo-Nazi terror network.## He wrote a three-page antisemitic# manifesto that praised Adolf Hitler.
He bought a drone and explosives, which# authorities allege he planned to use in an attack.## The teen shared that plan with others, including a# Russian speaker, and intended to flee to Ukraine.
The FAA says the tour company whose sightseeing# helicopter crashed into the Hudson River in New## York City last week is shutting down effective# immediately.
The chopper from New York Helicopter## Tours broke apart in midair, killing a# family of five Spanish tourists and the## pilot.
The FAA also said it would review the tour# company's operating license and safety record.
In total, five sightseeing helicopters# have crashed into New York City's rivers## in the past two decades.
They# remain a popular tourist draw.
Turning overseas, former South Korean# President Yoon Suk Yeol denied criminal## charges that he led an insurrection when# he declared martial law late last year.## He was ousted from office just 10 days ago# for that short-lived martial law attempt.
Today, Yoon told the court that martial law# is not a coup d'etat.
Prosecutors said the## former president tried to paralyze# state institutions like Parliament.## Yoon's lawyers said he was fully# within his constitutional authority.
YOON KAB-KEUN, Attorney for Yoon Suk Yeol# (through translator): During this trial,## we will fully explain why the president# ..
The prosecutors are now seeing this# as an insurrection.
We believe it can## be proven that this doesn't have to be# regarded as a crime in the first place.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: If Yoon is# convicted of mounting an insurrection,## the charges are punishable# by life in prison or death.
In Central Europe, Hungary's Parliament# passed a new constitutional amendment that## bans public LGBTQ events.
It set off# protests, including before the vote,## when demonstrators tried to block lawmakers# from entering.
They had to be physically## removed by police.
In the end, the vote was a# resounding 140 yes-votes, with only 21 against.
The new amendment also says that Hungary's# Constitution will only recognize two sexes,## male and female, a basis for denying the gender# identities of transgender people and others.
In Brazil, former President Jair# Bolsonaro remains in intensive## care today after undergoing a lengthy# 12-hour surgery for a bowel obstruction.## The far right leader has been hospitalized# since Friday for abdominal pain stemming## from when he was stabbed at a 2018 campaign# event.
Doctors say he's in stable condition,## all this as Bolsonaro is expected to face trial# on charges that he attempted to stage a coup## after his election loss in 2022, efforts that# were punctuated by riots led by his supporters.
And a passing of note.
Peruvian author and# Nobel laureate Mario Vargas Llosa has died.
The## acclaimed storyteller wrote about corruption# and cruelty, not just in his native Peru,## but across Latin America.
His novels, essays,# articles, and columns often drew on his own## experiences.
He attended military academy as# a boy and later wrote of military brutality.
He joined a communist cell in his teens and later# wrote against leftist society as one mired in## poverty and injustice.
His passion for politics# led to an unsuccessful presidential run in 1990.
In 2012, he spoke to the "News Hour" about# the power and moral imperative of literature.
MARIO VARGAS LLOSA, Author: I don't accept the# idea that literature can be just entertainment## and that there is no sequels, consequences of# literature in the real world.
If this is true, I## think it gives the writer a kind of responsibility# that is not only literary, but also moral.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Mario# Vargas Llosa was 89 years old.
Still to come on the "News Hour": Ukraine# reels from a Russian attack that killed dozens,## including children; Mark Zuckerberg takes# the stand at Meta's antitrust trial;## Tamara Keith and Amy Walter break down the# latest political headlines; plus much more.
There is more fallout from a Russian missile# strike in Northeast Ukraine that killed## dozens of civilians on Palm Sunday.
Ukrainian# President Volodymyr Zelenskyy called Russia## filthy scoundrels, while President Trump blamed# both Ukraine and Russia for the start of the war.
Nick Schifrin reports.
NICK SCHIFRIN: In a shattered Sumy# today, sorrow is stated with flow.. with childhood comforts, and with profound# grief of 20-year-old student Anisia Yaluzhko.
ANISIA YALUZHKO, Sumy Resident (through# translator): It hurts.
Every Ukrainian is hurt.
It## hurts.
It's scary to be here, but there's nowhere# else where I can find myself.
This is my home.
NICK SCHIFRIN: Yesterday, on Palm Sunday, a# Russian weapon designed to target infantry## hit the heart and mind of this city.
A# camera attached to a Ukrainian police## officer walking through destruction that# included a college found the dead among## the dust and debris and families alive, but# traumatized, others, an unspeakable loss.
In total, at least 35 killed, some inside their# cars burn beyond recognition.
The Russian cluster## bomb also ripped through a bus, where 13-year-old# Karilo Ilyashenko (ph) and his mother survived.
WOMAN (through translator): It all# happened so fast.
It got so dark when## the explosion happened.
Glass shattered# into our faces.
We touched each other,## but couldn't see each other, as it was still dark.
DONALD TRUMP, President of the United# States: I think it was terrible.
And## I was told they made a mistake.# But I think it's a hor.. NICK SCHIFRIN: Last night, President Trump# suggested the attack was inadvertent.
QUESTION: You mean it was unintentional?
DONALD TRUMP: They made a mistake.
BAIBA BRAZE, Latvian Minister of# .. what they were doing.
Th.. NICK SCHIFRIN: But, in Brussels# today, unanimous European horror.
RADOSLAW SIKORSKI, Polish Foreign Minister:# I hope that President Trump and the U.S.## administration see that the leader# of Russia is mocking their goodwill,## and I hope the right decisions are taken.
NICK SCHIFRIN: Just three days# ago, Trump envoy Steve Witkoff## held his hand to his heart as he met# Russian President Vladimir Putin.
Today, President Trump for the first# time accused Putin of launching the war,## but also falsely accused Ukraine of provoking it.
DONALD TRUMP: Biden could have stopped# it and Zelenskyy could have stopped it,## and Putin should have never# started it.
Everybody's to blame.
QUESTION: Have you spoken to President Zelenskyy,## sir, about his offer to purchase# more Patriot missile battles?
DONALD TRUMP: You don't start a war# against somebody that's 20 times your size,## and then hope that people give you some missiles.
NICK SCHIFRIN: That ambiguity has# challenged Ukrainian President## Volodymyr Zelenskyy's faith in U.S.# support, as he told CBS' 60 Minutes.
QUESTION: Does the United States have your back?
VOLODYMYR ZELENSKYY, Ukrainian President# (through translator): Even in this pause## of mine, there's a problem, because I# want to answer truthfully and quickly## that the United States is our strategic,# strong partner.
But the pause is doubt.
NICK SCHIFRIN: Today, Russian# Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov## claimed the target in Sumy was legitimate.
SERGEY LAVROV, Russian Foreign Minister# (through translator): There was yet## another mob up of the Ukrainia.. NICK SCHIFRIN: But, in Sumy today, there is# no evidence of that.
And as the U.S. pushes## peace, Russia continues its attacks.# Ukraine has no choice but to suffer,## no choice but to clean up the pieces.
For the "PBS News Hour," I'm Nick Schifrin.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: A blockbuster antitrust trial# kicks off today between Meta and the Federal Trade## Commission.
The government alleges the company,# which was then called Facebook, monopolized the## social media market when it purchased competitors# Instagram in 2012 and WhatsApp two years later.
Stephanie Sy is here to explore the# potential impact of the trial -- Stephanie.
STEPHANIE SY: William, the trial, which# is expected to last up to two months,## could have major implications for big tech.
If the social media giant loses, it# could be forced to break itself apart## and sell off both of those popular# platforms, including Instagram,## which is projected to make up more than# half of the company's ad revenue this year.
To help us understand the issues, we're# joined now by Rebecca Allensworth,## professor of law at Vanderbilt University.
Rebecca, thanks so much for# joining the "News Hour."
This is a case that has been years in the making.# And we know what the major battle lines already## are.
The government alleges that Meta used a# strategy to buy or bury other start-ups, killing## competition.
Does the FTC have a strong case on# that basis, that Meta has violated antitrust law?
REBECCA ALLENSWORTH, Vanderbilt University# Law School: So, it has a strong case on that## part of the case, about whether or not# the acquisition suppressed competition.
The weakest part of its case is actually whether# or not Facebook is a monopoly in the first place,## whether or not Meta is a monopoly.# It has to prove both monopoly power## and an act of exclusion that allowed# it to maintain that monopoly power.
But the problem for the government# is that there are potentially other## competitors that we could see# as major players in this space.
STEPHANIE SY: Meta's lawyer today called the## case a grab bag that was -- quote --# "at war with the facts and the law."
We saw -- or we heard that Mark# Zuckerberg himself testified today.## What are the strongest points of the defense and# do they have to do with the fact that so much has## changed in the social media landscape since# this case was first brought four years ago?
REBECCA ALLENSWORTH: This is not a grab# bag.
This is definitely a strong case.
So,## on the part of the government,# it's a very strong case.
As far as what are Meta's best arguments,# those have to do with market power and market## definition.
But their weakest arguments, the# strength of the government's case really comes## from these e-mails that Mark Zuckerberg# wrote about the acquisitions at the time,## where he really kind of laid out what we would# call in antitrust like an anticompetitive intent.
STEPHANIE SY: Mark Zuckerberg wrote in that# 2008 e-mail: "It is better to buy than compete."
But I want to go back to this point about the# changing landscape.
Some critics of the FTC's## case point out that so many other competitors have# sprung up, namely TikTok, in the last four years.## Does the government have more of an uphill battle# just given how quickly the landscape has changed?
REBECCA ALLENSWORTH: You're right to point# out that the landscape has changed a bit.
But,## at the same time, I think that the# government has a strong argument that,## in fact, Facebook, Meta is still a# monopolist and they have monopoly power.
And that's because, while people do sometimes# consume other social media platforms, they do## spend time on other platforms, they look at ads# on other platforms, they still view Facebook,## Facebook Blue, the product we all associate# with Facebook, as not having substitutes.
It's really one of the only ways# to stay in touch with your friends## and family.
The real question is, can# Facebook make their product worse and## not lose customers?
And we know that# they have done that over the years.
STEPHANIE SY: This is one of several# antitrust cases against big tech that## started years ago under the first Trump# administration and then, of course,## continued under Biden.
And we# have spoken about the landmark## ruling last year which found Google was# monopolizing the Internet search sphere.
Rebecca, do you see momentum gaining to rein in## big tech with antitrust law?
Is this# the case to continue that momentum?
REBECCA ALLENSWORTH: I do see that momentum.# And it's not just these cases.
It comes from## some of the merger cases too, even# the ones that the government lost.
There were all kinds of theories# that were endorsed in those cases,## those little data points that courts are# ready to shift the momentum of antitrust## away from laissez-faire and start really# taking big companies to task for doing## things that are anticompetitive,# especially digital monopolies.
Now, the big one here obviously is the# verdict in the search case.
But I think## we're probably about to get another win# for the government on another Google case,## another monopolization case in the ad# tech case.
And I don't know exactly## how that will go, but I think there's# a good chance the government will win.
And I think, if the government wins# this third case, that's a real kind## of tidal wave of liability# for these digital platforms.
STEPHANIE SY: How much does the political# landscape in Trump 2.0 potentially impact## the outcome here?
We know that Mark Zuckerberg# has been lobbying hard for a settlement.
And,## of course, he was at President# Trump's inauguration this year.## It's been a bipartisan issue# largely at least until now.
Do you see that changing?
REBECCA ALLENSWORTH: It's impossible# to know what this means and how it## will matter.
It's just too unpredictable.
We# don't know what happened in those meetings.
I think what we know is that Trump views# the FTC as being under his control,## which is legally incorrect and not the# way the agency was designed.
And yet## he fired the two Democrats on the FTC in# a strong signal that this is my agency,## this is my policy.
We also know, of course,# that Mark Zuckerberg has cozied up to him## and trying to take advantage of that control# that Trump is trying to wield over the FTC.
But whether it's in it -- whether there's# something in it for Trump to actually do this,## whether he actually will interfere on behalf# of Mark Zuckerberg and Meta more generally,## is totally unclear to me.
There would have# to be something in it for Trump and the Trump## administration.
And it was his administration# that brought this case in the first place.
It also seems, like if he was going to# do it, he would do it before now.
So## it's just a real mystery what will# happen there.
It's quite possible.
STEPHANIE SY: OK, something to keep our eye on.
Rebecca Allensworth with# Vanderbilt University, thank you.
REBECCA ALLENSWORTH: Thank you.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: In the ongoing effort to curb# climate change, scientists are taking aim at a## surprisingly potent source of the greenhouse# gases that are warming our planet, cows.
As part of our Tipping Point series, science# correspondent Miles O'Brien traveled from## California to Mexico and even to Australia to# explore a bold idea that could make a big impact.
MILES O'BRIEN: It's 0 dark 30 at the Straus# Dairy Farm in Marin County, California.
The## cows stand patiently in line, ready for the# morning milking.
At the helm is Albert Straus.
ALBERT STRAUS, Straus Family Creamery:# I want to make a farming system that's a## positive impact on the environment, at the# same time produce high-quality organic food.
MILES O'BRIEN: So methane is never far from# his mind.
It's an especially potent greenhouse## gas.
Over 20 years, it traps about 80 times# more heat than carbon dioxide.
Dairy cows and## beef cattle emit a significant amount of it.
It# mostly comes from their burps, not flatulence.
In fact, methane emissions from livestock exceed# the oil and gas industry.
It's a stubborn problem.## And, for Albert, it threatens to derail his# goal of achieving carbon neutrality by 2030.
ALBERT STRAUS: Cows have an essential# role in reversing climate change.
MILES O'BRIEN: That's why, in 2021, he# jumped at the chance to become the first## commercial dairy in the U.S. to test# a novel methane mitigation solution,## seaweed in the feed.
He enrolled# two dozen cows in a two-month trial.
ALBERT STRAUS: The things that we were testing for# didn't have any effects on animal health or human## health.
There was no off-flavors or effects on the# quality of the milk or the quantity of the milk.
MILES O'BRIEN: The additive comes from a# red seaweed called asparagopsis taxiformis.## It was less than a half-a-percent of the# cows' diet, but the results were dramatic.
ALBERT STRAUS: An average of 52 percent reduction,## with some cows over 80 percent,# and then one cow over 90 percent.
MILES O'BRIEN: University of California# Davis animal University of California## Davis animal scientist Ermias# Kebreab consulted on the study.## He is a world leader in the quest to# cut methane emissions from livestock.
ERMIAS KEBREAB, University of California, Davis:# I think we can produce high-quality protein,## high-quality milk, at the# same time help the planet.
MILES O'BRIEN: To gather data on how# much methane a cow might be exhaling,## they use a device called GreenFeed.
As# the cows lick, chew, breathe, and belch,## the gases they exhale are sucked# into a tube for real-time analysis.
ERMIAS KEBREAB: So it will# analyze the contents of the## breath in different concentrations of the gases.
MILES O'BRIEN: Hello.
How are you.
How are you?
They are recording impressive results.# Cows that consume just a quarter of 1## percent seaweed in their diet# emit 30 percent less methane.
ERMIAS KEBREAB: We are kind of slowly# introducing the higher dose now.
MILES O'BRIEN: What do you# think the upward limit is?
ERMIAS KEBREAB: In the literature, there# is a report that 98 percent reduction.
MILES O'BRIEN: Ninety-eight?
ERMIAS KEBREAB: Ninety-eight..
MILES O'BRIEN: And that's with only# one-half of 1 percent seaweed additive.
So,## why do cows produce so much# methane?
To understand that,## we need to ruminate literally on the# rumen, the first of four compartments## in a cows stomach.
Here, microbes start the# whole process of turning grass into energy.
But this fermentation also releases# carbon dioxide, CO2, and hydrogen,## H2.
With the help of a special enzyme, those# molecules are converted to methane, CH4,## and exhaled.
But this process can be disrupted# by an ingredient in seaweed called bromoform.## It disables that enzyme, preventing# the CO2 and H2 from forming methane.
And the hydrogen is now for the cow.
Effective as# it appears to be, a lot of it needs to be grown## to make a dent in livestock methane production.# That's what they are working on here in Mexico,## 140 miles south of San Diego in the tiny# community of Ejido Erendira.
The U.S. start-up## that performed the study at the Straus Dairy# Farm is shifting into large-scale production.
This is the Blue Ocean Barns seaweed farm.
HANNAH RESETARITS, Blue Ocean Barns:# So this is called the sun tube.
MILES O'BRIEN: The senior manager of operations# expansion, Hannah Resetarits, gave me a .. HANNAH RESETARITS: All of our# cultures start in this room and## then scale outside all the way up# through our different vessel sizes.
MILES O'BRIEN: Outdoors, they scale# up in 17,000-gallon shallow vessels.## Scientists are still learning what# the seaweed likes and what it doesn't.
You're trying to scale up and still understand## some basic science at the same# time, which is a challenge, right?
HANNAH RESETARITS: Oh, 100 percent, yes.
It is# something that makes this job very exciting.
It## also means that, as we go, we are also going# back and improving our systems every day.
MILES O'BRIEN: Joan Salwen is the# co-founder and CEO of Blue Ocean Barns.
JOAN SALWEN, Co-Founder and CEO, Blue Ocean# Barns: It became clear that this kind of## finicky seaweed was not just going to become# domesticated without a little bit of a fight.
MILES O'BRIEN: The company has raised# $35 million.
It is in talks with some## major food producers, scrambling for# ways to meet carbon neutrality targets.
JOAN SALWEN: Not one of them will get to# carbon neutral without our product.
And if## they continue to feel pressure to make good# on their promise, I feel very, very bullish.
MILES O'BRIEN: Nice one.
But she does face a serious roadblock.
In the# U.S., the Food and D.. category for products aimed at reducing# greenhouse gases.
If bromoform from## seaweed is considered a veterinary drug, the# approval process might take five to 10 years,## far too long, given the# urgency of the climate crisis.
JOAN SALWEN: We're a little# stuck in the United States.
MILES O'BRIEN: Studies show no toxicity and no## adverse effects.
Australia has already# approved seaweed feed for livestock.
I'm going to have a simply# grilled with cheese, please.
SAM ELSOM, Co-Founder and CEO, Sea# Forest: Yes, two of those, thank you.
MILES O'BRIEN: In fact, low-methane burgers have# been on the market down under for two years.## I tried one in Sydney with Sam Elsom, co-founder# and CEO of the Tasmania-based seaweed producer Sea## Forest.
Australia didn't classify the additive# as a drug, which made approval much faster.
SAM ELSOM: I'm grateful that we live in# Australia.
It should happen in the U.S.,## for sure.
It should happen all around the world.
MILES O'BRIEN: It's a solution# without a negative that I could taste.
(LAUGHTER) SAM ELSOM: That's true.
MILES O'BRIEN: Scientists say we must cut# global greenhouse gas em.. 2030 in order to limit global warming to 2.7# degrees Fahrenheit.
But we are headed in the## opposite direction.
Emissions are still rising.
As# it turns out, a big solution might be bite-sized.
For the "PBS News Hour," I'm Miles# O'Brien in Sydney, Australia.
Amy Walter, Tamara Keith WILLIAM BRANGHAM:## The political fallout from the Trump# administration's tariff policies continues,## and intraparty fighting seems to be breaking# out with both Democrats and Republicans.
For analysis, we are joined by Amy Walter of The## Cook Political Report With Amy# Walter and Tamara Keith of NPR.
Welcome to you both.
AMY WALTER, The Cook Political Report.. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Tam, sorry to no.. but you look great, huge at# the end of the table there.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: First question to you.# I don't know if you heard.
We had David## Wessel on the program earlier talking# about the economic crater that this## has blown into the U.S. economy and how the# future does not really seem all that clear.
What have the political repercussions been# for the president and his administration?
TAMARA KEITH: I think that there are# repercussions, even though the policy## is a little bit unclear, or it seems# like it changes every 48 hours or so.
And various Trump administration officials are# delivering different messages depending on what## show they're on.
And then President Trump will# come out on social media and say something else,## for instance, his social media post saying# that there were no exceptions for electronics,## they're still being tariffed, and# also there might be more to come.
What the consequences end up being is that# consumer sentiment is in a very bad place.## And consumer sentiment also then goes forward# into sentiment about the president's performance## on the economy.
It is his weakest point.
It# is -- of all of the things that are polled## in terms of the president's performance, his# performance on the economy is at the bottom,## which is remarkable because he came into office as# the businessman who was going to shake things up.
He came into office -- and generally Republicans# are viewed more favorably on the economy.
So to## have that as his weak point does indicate# that there is something happening here,## that consumers are worried about# a recession, and that polling -- a## CBS poll over the weekend indicated a large# share of voters, including many Republicans,## believe that prices are going to get higher as a# result of this policy, at least in the short term.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Right.
I mean, and that, Amy, is certainly disastrous for#an administration.
I mean, does ... about-face, the tariffs are on, well, now they're# off, indicate that he is feeling that pressure.
AMY WALTER: I don't know.
I mean, I do think that he firmly believes and has#firmly believed for the last 40 years t... is the right policy and that, as he does in many# things, sometimes, the policy is not as organized## as many people would like to see, but that it --# but it will work out at the end of the day.
And I## think that's why you have so many Republicans# still sticking with him, including voters.
That CBS poll finds most Republicans willing# to give him some time for this to work out,## even as they're saying, yes, in the short term,# we expect prices to rise.
There's also a little## bit of a silver lining in some of this# polling that we're seeing.
While his... WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Silver lining for the president.
AMY WALTER: For the president, yes, for him.
Even as consumers -- as Tam points out,# consumers are nervous and his handling## of the economy has dropped off in recent in# recent weeks, what we're also seeing is that## 51 percent of voters in the CBS polls# say that they like the idea of what he's## trying to get at.
It's that 65 percent of# them don't like the way he's going at it.
So that... AMY WALTER: The idea that there's a need for these#.. obviously, Democrats aren't giving the president# any credit.
Republicans are all with him.
Among independent voters, more than 60 percent of# them in the CBS poll said they're willing to wait## a few weeks, months, even up to a year for these# to work themselves out.
And so while the chaos of## it is exhausting, is taking a toll for consumers# and for the president's overall approval rating,## he may actually have some more time for this# to get to a place that people feel like, oh,## OK, either that wasn't so bad or# maybe we're in a better place.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Tamara, I want to pivot to the# Democrats for a second and sort of a bind that## they seem to be in.
I mean, on the one hand, you# have Democrats that -- especially state governors,## who feel like they have to talk to the president# to try to dodge the incoming fire of his tariffs.
But you also have a base that very much# wants them to fight like hell against## him.
And we saw that in those protests# that erupted around the country recently.## There was this remarkable example that# happened here in Washington where Michigan## Governor Gretchen Whitmer came to Washington,# D.C., to talk to President Trump about this.
But apparently she was dragged into a photo-op# that she didn't want to be a part of.
And The## New York Times had this incredible photograph of# her basically covering her face as if to indicate,## I'm not cozying up to the president, dear voters,# who you want me to be hitting with a big club.
Describe a little bit the bind that# the Democrats find themselves in.
TAMARA KEITH: Yes, and I think governors# in particular find themselves in a bind.## You have Governor Whitmer hiding# behind that folder and then just## getting taken to task on social media.# Not that social media is real life,## but people saying, and that's the# day she lost the race for president.
I don't know that that's -- I think that's# overstating the case.
But the challenge for## governors is that they do need the federal# government.
They need federal assistance## when there are disasters.
They need those# Medicaid payments.
They -- essentially, they## need to somehow work with the federal government# because that's the way our government functions at## the same time that at any given moment President# Trump could turn on them, could withhold funding,## could -- as he's been doing with universities# and going after the state of Maine, for instance.
And so governors are in an incredibly challenging# position just trying to govern and lead their## states at this time where the president of the# United States could turn on them at any moment,## but where their voters, as you say, do really# want change.
They want a fighter.
They want## someone to aggressively hit back at the president,# though, yes, they're just a little bit stuck.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: And, Amy, there's also this# frustration we have been seeing vented most## recently by a lot of progressive Democrats# challenging sitting Democrats in House races,## also Bernie Sanders and Alexandria# Ocasio-Cortez getting tens of thousands## of people out on a very economic# populist fight the president message.
AMY WALTER: Right.
I think what we're seeing more than anything#is one -- much more of style than ideology.## Somebody, I heard the other day saying what# Democrats are fighting about is not to be## more progressive, but to be more aggressive,# especially when it comes to Donald Trump.
Where that gets them, though, is the -- really# the next question because fundamentally,## and this is where I think Whitmer was going,# which is you not only have to work with the## president because I'm a governor of a state# and for all the reasons Tam pointed out,## you need federal assistance, but also what# do the Democrats stand for economically?
And that's going to be the# big question going forward.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Amy Walter, Tamara# Keith, great to have you both.
Thank you.
AMY WALTER: You're welcome.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM:## In 2023, we told you about# the debut of an acclaimed## young blues musician named Nat Myers of Kentucky.
"American Songwriter" said his work# -- quote -- "reverberates with the## sound of a deep blues man from the 20s and 30s."
Special correspondent Tom Casciato now# has an update to Myers personal story.## It's part of our arts and culture series, Canvas.
TOM CASCIATO: Nat Myers sings and# plays the blues like the last 100## years of music never even happened.
He# plays his resonator guitar that way too.
I first met Nat in 2023, when he was fresh off# the release of his critically praised debut album,## "Yellow Peril."
He'd been discovered# by the Black Keys' Dan Auerbach,## who signed and recorded him in Nashville.# We talked about his love of literature,## existentialists like Albert Camus# and the ancients, especially Homer.
NAT MYERS, Musician: You don't see the# fall of Troy.
You don't see the Trojan## horse.
You don't see these things.
You# see a moment after Patroclus is killed.
TOM CASCIATO: And he spoke of Charley# Patton, an artist who inspired his style,## and others like Mississippi's# Robert Petway and Tommy McClennan.
Nat Myers' career was taking off.
Less than two# years later, his life has taken a different turn.
NAT MYERS: I felt something was# wrong with me maybe back in November,## but I started getting these what I described as# pleuritic pains running up and down the kind of## the -- back of my ribs.
I felt like my ribs and# my lungs were just like scraping each other.
So I## thought maybe I just got a lung infection and some# anti-inflammatories and stuff would help me out.
So I went down maybe 30 seconds after leaving that## urgent care.
I got a call from# the doctor and she was like,## yes, I think we're dealing with something a# little different here than some inflammation.
TOM CASCIATO: In February, Nat would reveal on# social media that he'd been laid low by cancer,## a rare sarcoma with growths around# his heart and pulmonary arteries.
NAT MYERS: I can't tell you, Tom.# They were sure I was going to die.## I got some lifesaving surgeries.
And# I just always thought about Camus## talking about the absurdity of life# striking a man in the face any day.
And if surgery and life struck me in the face,## but I reacted very, very well to my first round# of chemotherapy.
I have also joined the club.
TOM CASCIATO: I want to officially# welcome you to the club now.
The 34-year-old Kentuckian is# being treated in Columbus, Ohio,## his care paid for in part by an# online fund-raising campaign.
NAT MYERS: You know, everybody says one step at# a -- one day at a time, but, one day at a time,## I have found it as terrifying.# For instance, I had a PET scan## yesterday.
I wasn't sure whether or not# the cancer spread to my brain, you know?
TOM CASCIATO: Wow.
NAT MYERS: And to find out tha..
It's like every day becomes a poker game.# It's a crazy thing.
It's a crazy thing.
TOM CASCIATO: When we first spoke in 2023,# Nat talked about his passion for playing live.
NAT MYERS: A lot of people say they play music# for the fans or they make the music for these## people.
Like, we do this all for you.
I don't# abide that, because I do this music because,## like, literally I'd die if I# weren't playing this stuff.
TOM CASCIATO: Are you able to play now?
NAT MYERS: Oh, yes, thank the lord.
Blues# continues to be my outlet and my saving## grace.
I remember this lady down in South Carolina# when I was after two-and-a-half weeks bedridden.
She came into my room as I was# about to leave and she pointed## at the guitar and she said: "Are you a musician?"
And I said; "Yes, ma'am."
And she was like: "Well, you keep playing on# that because that's going to be your healing."
I look at old videos of blues musicians I# love like Fred McDowell when he was playing## in the early '70s.
He died in '71 of cancer.
And# I look at him and I see the veins pulsing and him## struggling.
And I realize that we're years apart,# but we're in the exact same position.
And even## despite his -- even despite his struggles, he was# still playing music wherever he could for people.
I hope one day to be able to play music for people# again.
It's the greatest thrill of my life, so... TOM CASCIATO: For the "PBS# News Hour," I'm Tom Casciato.
WILLIAM BRANGHAM: What a beautiful young man.# We wish him all the healing in the world.
That is the "News Hour" for# tonight.
I'm William Brangham.
On behalf of the entire "News Hour"# team, thank you so much for joining us.
Blues musician Nat Myers faces battle with a rare cancer
Video has Closed Captions
Acclaimed blues musician Nat Myers faces battle with a rare cancer (5m 22s)
Farmers turn to seaweed to reduce methane emissions
Video has Closed Captions
Farmers turn to seaweed in attempt to reduce methane emissions from livestock (7m 45s)
How Meta's antitrust trial could have major implications
Video has Closed Captions
How Meta's blockbuster antitrust trial could have major implications for big tech (6m 2s)
News Wrap: Penn. arson suspect charged with terrorism
Video has Closed Captions
News Wrap: Man accused of targeting Shapiro charged with attempted homicide and terrorism (5m 42s)
Russian cluster bomb attack on Ukraine kills dozens
Video has Closed Captions
Russian cluster bomb attack on Ukraine kills dozens, including children (3m 57s)
Tamara Keith and Amy Walter on voters and Trump's policies
Video has Closed Captions
Tamara Keith and Amy Walter on what voters think about Trump's economic policies (7m 47s)
Tariff confusion injects more uncertainty into economy
Video has Closed Captions
Confusion over electronics tariffs injects more uncertainty into economy (8m 2s)
Trump, El Salvador reject responsibility for deported man
Video has Closed Captions
Trump, El Salvador's president indicate no intention of returning mistakenly deported man (6m 51s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSupport for PBS provided by:
Major corporate funding for the PBS News Hour is provided by BDO, BNSF, Consumer Cellular, American Cruise Lines, and Raymond James. Funding for the PBS NewsHour Weekend is provided by...